Sunday, August 31, 2025

A comforting denial

I recently applied for a long-term health care policy and was turned-down.

The phone interview, done by an RN, was “interesting.”

Early into the call:

“What operations have you had in the past.”

“I’ve had bilateral total hip replacements.”

“Why?”

“I had advanced degenerative joint disease.”

“Oh, okay.”

A bit later:

“Have you had any abnormal X-ray studies in the past?”

“Yes, on my hips.”

“What was abnormal on the right hip X-ray?”

“It showed advanced DJD.”

“What was the outcome?”

“I had a total right hip replacement.”

“Oh (and not, oh yeah) okay, what was abnormal on the left hip X-ray?”

Me, after briefly contemplating if I was being punked:

“It showed advanced DJD.”

“What was the outcome?”

“I had a left total hip replacement.”

“Oh, okay, let’s move on to some additional questions.”

The interview continued with more questions, many of which were redundant.

Clearly the RN was reading through a list of questions, having had to, hopefully only temporarily, abandon her common-sense once our encounter had commenced.

Prior to the call, I had looked into what to expect for the over-the-phone cognitive screen.

One question always apparent was, “in the next minute, name as many animals as you can.”

(Naming 15 or more is considered normal)

I was ready.

However, I was queried , “in the next minute, name as many fruits and vegetables as you can.”

Despite being temporarily stunned, I quickly recovered and proceeded to peel (pun intended) off, greater than 30.

A few weeks later a thin envelope arrived with the insurance company logo.

Remembering college application days from the 70s, when a thin envelope was consistent with being denied acceptance, I knew a disapproval was most likely before I opened the letter.

However, I was oddly comforted: “A long-term health care policy cannot be underwritten due to having had bilateral hip replacements.”

There was no inkling of cognitive deficits!

I admit…I’d prefer to be somewhat functionally impaired and cognitively intact than the alternative-functionally intact and cognitively impaired-before leaving earth!

No comments:

Post a Comment

Something totally non-medical

Something totally non-medical An editorial in The Journal of Family Practice (1) , from thirty years ago, significantly impacted my career...