Sunday, August 31, 2025

A comforting denial

I recently applied for a long-term health care policy and was turned-down.

The phone interview, done by an RN, was “interesting.”

Early into the call:

“What operations have you had in the past.”

“I’ve had bilateral total hip replacements.”

“Why?”

“I had advanced degenerative joint disease.”

“Oh, okay.”

A bit later:

“Have you had any abnormal X-ray studies in the past?”

“Yes, on my hips.”

“What was abnormal on the right hip X-ray?”

“It showed advanced DJD.”

“What was the outcome?”

“I had a total right hip replacement.”

“Oh (and not, oh yeah) okay, what was abnormal on the left hip X-ray?”

Me, after briefly contemplating if I was being punked:

“It showed advanced DJD.”

“What was the outcome?”

“I had a left total hip replacement.”

“Oh, okay, let’s move on to some additional questions.”

The interview continued with more questions, many of which were redundant.

Clearly the RN was reading through a list of questions, having had to, hopefully only temporarily, abandon her common-sense once our encounter had commenced.

Prior to the call, I had looked into what to expect for the over-the-phone cognitive screen.

One question always apparent was, “in the next minute, name as many animals as you can.”

(Naming 15 or more is considered normal)

I was ready.

However, I was queried , “in the next minute, name as many fruits and vegetables as you can.”

Despite being temporarily stunned, I quickly recovered and proceeded to peel (pun intended) off, greater than 30.

A few weeks later a thin envelope arrived with the insurance company logo.

Remembering college application days from the 70s, when a thin envelope was consistent with being denied acceptance, I knew a disapproval was most likely before I opened the letter.

However, I was oddly comforted: “A long-term health care policy cannot be underwritten due to having had bilateral hip replacements.”

There was no inkling of cognitive deficits!

I admit…I’d prefer to be somewhat functionally impaired and cognitively intact than the alternative-functionally intact and cognitively impaired-before leaving earth!

No comments:

Post a Comment

My most recent esay for the narrative medicine certification

  The Art of Medicine and the Twilight Zone The practice of medicine encompasses both art and science. “Three patients may find themselv...